Research Blog #2

Currently I am trying to get a little more specific with my topic. I want to see the academic and social success of students who commuted vs. living on campus once they graduated from school. By doing this I can make my thoughts much more clear.

Doing some research has net me a lot of results that relate to the academic success of students who commute vs. dorm. Many web pages, PDF articles, and scholarly books conduct research on this very study. Th Some of these key terms include, integration, time management, and social networking. From what I have read these key terms exist in different realms for those that commute and those that live on campus. The articles all discuss how students who live on-campus have a higher chance for success than students who commute to school.

Some resources I found were, "Living on Campus: Does it still Make a Difference?" by Polly A. Graham, Sarah Hurtado, and Robert Gonyea research on first-year students from a University in Indiana. They came to the conclusion that students who live off-campus have a harder time getting access to the same convenient social and academic resources that students who live on campus do. The article, "The Disenganged Commuter Student: Fact or Fiction?" by George Kuh, Robert Gonyea, and Megan Palmer discuss how college residential programs, put a great deal of effort in making students that dorm much more prepared for student-life. These include networking, opportunities for tutoring, and joining social groups.

A counter-point to this argument is in the one particular article I discovered was, "College Living Environments and Stress: Commuters Versus On-Campus Residency" by Alicia Horvath. Horvath conducted a study on 30 students from the Introduction Psychology courses of a regional state university in the Midwest. The study found that students who lived off-campus had slightly lower stress levels, due to living in a familiar atmosphere.

1. Living on Campus: Does it Still Make a Difference?
By. Polly A. Graham, Sarah S. Hurtado, & Robert M. Gonyea


2. The Disengaged Commuter Student: Fact or Fiction?
By George D. Kuh, Robert M. Gonyea, Megan Palmer 

3. College Living Environments and Stress: Commuters Versus On-Campus Residency
By Alicia Horvath

Comments

  1. Michael GoellerOctober 3, 2017 at 5:39 AM

    The counter-point article did not have a very large sample size as the basis of its research. What's more, I think its argument about "stress" might be a little flawed, as there is research (discussed in the popular book The Upside of Stress) that suggests a certain level of stress is good and helps students learn and grow. Living at home with parents who support you might lead to complacency which can feed the disengagement from school or allow students to accept lower grades and lower success knowing that their parents will always support them.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Research Blog #1

Image
Topic: On-Campus vs. Commuting I have been a commuter for the majority of my attendance at Rutgers. My first year I was a resident  at the University and resided in a dorm. In order to save money I moved back home, and have been commuting to school for the last three years. I believe that commuting and residing at the dorms each had there pros and cons for my academic and social college experience. I would like to research the statistics of students who both dormed and then commuted and their academic performance as a result. I would also like to look at their social life and if they preferred one over the other.
Read more

Research Blog #8

Case   Because commuter students tend to be from lower to middle class backgrounds, are usually first-generation college students, and are usually less affluent than their residential counterparts I plan on using Elizabeth Armstrong and Laura Hamilton's book Paying for the Party to make a real world representation of my frame. While, Armstrong and Hamilton's book does not expressly use commuter students in their study, they do use residential students who share many of the same qualities. They use students who work part time jobs, are poorer than the normal resident student, and find themselves with fewer  opportunities to take advantage of all of their university's resources. As a result these students are usually socially isolated from their dorm mates. These issues are all similar to the ones that commuter students face. One of the examples I plan on using in the book is of Amanda. Due to her status as a less affluent student she found it hard to find a common connect...
Read more

Literature Review #1

Image
John J. Newbold John J. Newbold, Sanjay S. Mehta, Patricia Forbus. "Commuter Students: Involvement and Identification with Institution of Higher Education."  Academy of Educational Leadership Journal . Pg 141-153 (2011). The reading discusses the conflicts students have with commuting to college. Their academic performances, involvement with their school, and relationships on campus are all affected by their off-campus lifestyle. Part-time work, family, and the stresses of travel are all factors that can affect their academic lives as well. Newbold, Mehta, and Forbus discuss their findings compared to their data on students who reside on campus. The authors for this paper are Dr. John J. Newbold, Sanjay S. Mehta, and Patricia Forbus who are all professors at Sam Houston University in Tennessee. They each are certified marketing professors and have written several papers regarding student struggles in relation to commuting. They together written an article called, Un...
Read more